If you can find a clean 2005 STi, buy it!2004 was the
first model year STi, & usually a first model year should be avoided, if possible.
(Granted, the '04 wasn't deeply flawed, but '05 added 1/2" rim width, yaw sensing, & that's a great improvement, along with many other odds n' ends, some quite important, some, cosmetic.)
California & Florida's got lots of F/S STIs, look into eBay, as well.
Don't be afraid to travel, cars in the NE take a beating, unless stored.
$20-$23K will get you an about-perfect STi, if you drop $30K, you can buy a magazine-cover grade, built STi.
A "Modified Magazine" cover STi, w at least $80K in it, sold on eBay three mos. ago for $28K.
It was a 95 point car, easily. Those are easier to come by, the $30K STi "monster car", than you'd think.
eBay will shock you.
Keep us posted on your search, and good luck.
Oh yeah-Welcome to MS!